On paper, it seems fairly simple: some hybrid of the merits
and tastes. And for the most part, it
does indeed work that way. Looking at my
lists of both merits and personal taste, I see that both the Smiths and Stevie
Ray Vaughan And Double Trouble make the top five in both categories. Naturally, both of those go on my
ballot. The Marvelettes just missed the
Top 5 on one and just made the Top 5 on the other, so they’d probably get my
vote as well. Despite being in the
bottom half of merit, they ran second in taste, so the Spinners have an average
that’s tied with the Marvelettes, and would get the vote from me as well. The fifth highest average of merit and
preference is N.W.A, who despite being in the bottom five for personal
enjoyment, are a solid second in terms of deserving induction. So, reasonably, I should be casting my ballot
for Stevie Ray Vaughan And Double Trouble, the Smiths, the Marvelettes, the
Spinners, and N.W.A.
Pretty simple, right?
And if that were the class that was inducted, I’d be pretty happy. I’d also shit bricks because there’s no way
this class is happening, but that’s for another entry. Just like probably everyone else who reads
this, I’ve submitted a fan ballot several times on the Rock Hall’s website, and
every time, four of those five names have indeed been checked off. However, instead of N.W.A. getting the fifth,
I’ve been waffling mostly between Bill Withers and War. Sometimes Bill Withers who finished sixth in
averages, and sometimes War, who despite being tied for ninth in averages, was
seventh in personal taste. Sometimes I
did vote for N.W.A., too, though. In
short, it seems that if I were a member of the voting bloc, it’s clear where
four of my votes would go, while the fifth would take some time to figure
out. And I gotta say that’s pretty
accurate. For me.
But I’m giving equal weight to personal preferences as to
merits. Others have a different weight
scale. Like my fiancé for example, who
admittedly is only doing this because I hamper her about it. Sorry honey.
Anyway, if she applied my logic and went with the averages of her taste
and how she feels they stack up objectively, her ballot would be cast for
Stevie Ray Vaughan And Double Trouble, Bill Withers, Green Day, the
Marvelettes, and Sting. Sixth place, by
the way, went to Joan Jett And The Blackhearts.
Yet, she’s not as attached to the artists on this ballot for personal
enjoyment, Green Day being the only one she really loves, with the top five
being filled out with Bill Withers, Sting, Joan Jett And The Blackhearts, and
Stevie Ray Vaughan And Double Trouble (sixth place: the Marvelettes). However, she’s admitted that when it comes to
actually casting a ballot, she’d stick strictly to her merits ranking. Her top five by her definitions of merits
sees it going Stevie Ray Vaughan And Double Trouble, the Smiths, the
Marvelettes, N.W.A., and Bill Withers, with Sting being the sixth optional
(don’t ask me, it’s her merits).
Similarly, consider the opinion of
PopeCharming/AlexVoltaire, whose Northumbrian blog was kind enough to plug mine
a few times, and for which, thank you.
His top six for merits were Kraftwerk, N.W.A., Green Day, Stevie Ray
Vaughan And Double Trouble, Nine Inch Nails, and Bill Withers. His personal preferences saw the top six
ranked as Bill Withers, the Spinners, Stevie Ray Vaughan And Double Trouble,
Sting, War, and Green Day. When you take
both ranks of all fifteen nominees, his top five are Stevie Ray Vaughan And
Double Trouble, Bill Withers, Kraftwerk, Green Day, and the Spinners, with a near
miss by War in sixth place. At the end
of that entry, where he said for whom he’d cast his vote, he did indeed choose
the first four, but instead of the Spinners for number five, he selected
N.W.A., stating that if he had a sixth and seventh choice, then he’d cast for
the Spinners and War (N.W.A. tied for seventh on his averages, tied with Chic).
Another perspective comes from Tom Lane, who didn’t rank
them by merits or taste per se, but simply put the nominees in a pecking order
by likelihood to vote for them. However,
reading his rationale behind each pecking point, it’s fairly clear that he was
swayed much more by personal taste than by whom he felt deserved the honors
more. His top five were the Spinners,
Chic, Stevie Ray Vaughan And Double Trouble, the Smiths, and War.
These are all important because as much as they might try to
deny it, members of the voting bloc are also humans and likewise afflicted by
the need to reconcile personal tastes with how seminal an artist really
is. And with some of them, artists
especially, personal relationships with the nominees are a factor too. It’s generally accepted by those of us on the
outside that the only reason Chic has ever been nominated is because of the ties
between Nile Rodgers and current NomCom members. Cronyism seems to be a big factor. Cronyism is also what is usually referred to
when nay-sayers claim that “it’s all political,” but what about literal
politics? Political activism that
resonates with the political beliefs of voters probably played a factor in the
decision to vote in people like Bonnie Raitt and Jackson Browne so quickly,
while differing politics may have been a factor in what kept an act like Alice
Cooper off the ballot for so long, and continues to keep others like Ted Nugent
or Pat Boone eternally out of the Hall.
Even if not on the politically opposite end of the spectrum, being a
neutral can be enough to rub them the wrong way, i.e. whoever’s not with us is
against us. It could even be a factor in
determining why Tom Morello from Rage Against The Machine is a NomCom member
and not Alice Cooper, nee Vincent Furnier, or Lars Ulrich. In all fairness, we laypeople aren’t entirely
immune from the influence of politics either, but we are less inclined to
consider it seriously as a factor when deciding who deserves enshrinement and
who doesn’t, possibly because we don’t get to anyway.
But for now we still have the fan ballot, and as
infinitesimal as our individual, repeatedly cast vote is to the total ballot
and the entire vote overall, it’s still something that we owe it to ourselves
to be conscientious of why we choose those that we do. It’ll also give our future gripes with the
Hall more credence among each other, but that’s just a fringe benefit. With the growth of the impact of grassroots
campaigns to get artists inducted, knowing ourselves first will help us more
effectively reach out to them.
In closing, I’m going to include the full list of my
fiancĂ©’s lists, both merits and personal taste, since I put her through this
every year, it’s not fair to her to not publish her lists. Enjoy.
Her Merit Rank
- Stevie
Ray Vaughan And Double Trouble
- The
Smiths
- The
Marvelettes
- N.W.A.
- Bill
Withers
- Sting
- Green
Day
- Chic
- Nine
Inch Nails
- Lou
Reed
- Joan
Jett And The Blackhearts
- The
Spinners
- War
- Kraftwerk
- The Paul Butterfield Blues Band
Her Personal Taste Rank
- Green
Day
- Bill
Withers
- Sting
- Joan
Jett And The Blackhearts
- Stevie
Ray Vaughan And Double Trouble
- The
Marvelettes
- The
Spinners
- The
Paul Butterfield Blues Band
- Nine
Inch Nails
- Lou Reed
- War
- Chic
- N.W.A.
- Kraftwerk
- The
Smiths
No comments:
Post a Comment